Bread and Butter Pickles : How to Make the Sweet and Tangy Classic at Home

Looking for a crispy, sweet, and tangy pickle that goes perfectly with sandwiches, burgers, and BBQ? Bread and Butter Pickles are an American classic that add a pop of flavor to almost any dish. Whether you’re new to pickling or just craving a nostalgic treat from grandma’s pantry, this easy recipe will walk you through every step. You’ll learn about the best ingredients, how to make them crunchy, and how to store them safely for months. Don’t miss our easy pickled okra recipe if you’re looking to expand your pickling game.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

What Are Bread and Butter Pickles?

The Curious History Behind the Name

The name “bread and butter pickles” might seem puzzling at first—there’s no bread or butter involved. These sweet and tangy pickles got their name during the Great Depression when they were often eaten between slices of bread and butter as a cheap meal. Farmers used to barter them for groceries, so the name stuck. These pickles became a staple in many American homes, loved for their balance of sweet and sour notes.

Difference Between Bread and Butter Pickles and Other Pickle Types

Not all pickles are created equal. Dill pickles are sour and garlicky, while bread and butter pickles are sweeter and include spices like mustard seed, turmeric, and cloves. Compared to kosher dills, bread and butter pickles have more sugar and complex spice notes. They’re more of a snacking or sandwich pickle rather than something you’d use in classic deli pairings.

Pickle Type	Flavor Profile	Common Uses
Bread and Butter	Sweet, tangy, spicy	Burgers, sandwiches, snacks
Dill Pickles	Sour, garlicky	Deli sandwiches, burgers
Gherkins	Very sweet, small	Cheese boards, snacking
Kosher Dill	Salty, garlicky	Sandwiches, chopped in salads

Flavor Profile and Common Uses

Bread and butter pickles have a distinct balance of sugar, vinegar, and spices. The result? A slightly spicy, sweet, and tangy bite that pairs wonderfully with rich meats and creamy dishes. They’re fantastic on fried chicken sandwiches, BBQ plates, and even tossed into potato salad for a zingy twist. Their iconic crinkle-cut look and satisfying crunch make them as visually appealing as they are tasty.

Ingredients You’ll Need for Homemade Bread and Butter Pickles

Best Cucumbers for Pickling

Start with the freshest pickling cucumbers you can find—ideally, firm and thin-skinned varieties like Kirby cucumbers. Avoid waxed cucumbers, as the coating prevents the brine from penetrating. If you’re growing your own or grabbing from a farmers’ market, freshness is key to crisp pickles.

The Essential Vinegar and Spices

What gives bread and butter pickles their signature flavor? A mixture of white distilled vinegar and apple cider vinegar (both with 5% acidity) combined with a generous amount of sugar and a blend of pickling spices. Common spice additions include:

• Mustard seeds
• Celery seeds
• Cloves (whole and ground)
• Allspice berries
• Turmeric
• Crushed red pepper flakes
• Cinnamon stick

These flavors build layers of complexity and contribute to the pickles’ golden hue. Check out our pickled banana peppers recipe for a similar spice blend with a kick.

Can You Substitute Ingredients?

Yes—but do so carefully. You can use kosher salt if pickling salt isn’t available, though avoid iodized table salt as it may cloud the brine. If you’re low on white vinegar, apple cider vinegar can work solo but may slightly alter the flavor. For a sugar substitute, consider turbinado sugar or a reduced-sugar version, but know it may affect preservation. Interested in low-sugar pickling? Learn more in our healthy pumpkin brownies recipe, where sugar swaps are also explored.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Bread and Butter Pickles

Prepping Cucumbers and Onions

Start by washing your cucumbers thoroughly to remove any dirt. Trim off the ends and slice them into ¼-inch rounds. Pair them with thinly sliced onions—yellow or white both work well. Mix them with pickling salt and let them chill under a layer of ice for at least 4 hours. This step pulls excess moisture and helps retain that perfect crunch you’re aiming for.

After chilling, rinse and drain the cucumbers and onions several times. This removes excess salt and helps balance the final flavor. Don’t skip this part—it makes a noticeable difference in both texture and taste.

Creating the Perfect Brine

In a large saucepan, combine the following ingredients to create your signature brine:

• 1¼ cups white distilled vinegar
• 1 cup apple cider vinegar
• 2¼ cups granulated sugar
• Pickling spices (mustard seed, red pepper flakes, celery seed, cloves, allspice, turmeric, cinnamon stick)

Bring the mixture to a boil, stirring until the sugar dissolves completely. Once boiling, add the cucumber and onion slices directly into the pot. Let the mixture return to a boil, then remove it from heat. Your pickles are nearly there!

Looking for another bold-flavored dish? Don’t miss our creamy broccoli cheese soup recipe for a hearty pairing to these sweet pickles.

Refrigerator Pickles vs. Canning Process

If you’re not into water-bath canning, the refrigerator method works beautifully:

• Transfer the hot pickles and brine into clean jars
• Cool to room temperature
• Store in the fridge for up to 3 months

Prefer a shelf-stable option? Use the water bath canning technique:

1. Fill sterilized jars with pickles and brine
2. Wipe rims clean, apply lids
3. Boil jars in a water bath for 15 minutes
4. Let them cool until lids “pop” to seal

Discover great ideas like canning cowboy candy if you’re in the mood to preserve more garden bounty.

Expert Tips for Perfectly Crunchy Pickles

Avoiding Soggy Pickles With Chilling Techniques

That 4-hour ice bath isn’t optional if you want crispy pickles. Cold temperatures help the cucumbers firm up, preventing them from becoming rubbery after brining. Some folks even go a step further—adding a small grape leaf or a pinch of alum to each jar for added crunch. These traditional methods have stood the test of time.

How Long to Wait Before Eating

While bread and butter pickles can technically be eaten within 24 hours, their flavor improves dramatically if you wait at least one week. After three weeks, the spices meld beautifully, and you’ll get that classic sweet-tangy balance in every bite. Patience pays off here.

Mistakes to Avoid When Pickling at Home

Here are a few pitfalls to steer clear of:

• Using waxed cucumbers – wax prevents brine absorption
• Skipping the salt soak – leads to mushy textures
• Using table salt – causes cloudy brine
• Incorrect vinegar acidity – less than 5% won’t preserve properly
• Overprocessing in the canner – softens your pickles

Looking for inspiration? Try our crispy baked zucchini slices for another veggie snack that brings the crunch.

Storing and Serving Your Bread and Butter Pickles

Shelf Life and Fridge Storage Tips

Refrigerator pickles will last up to 3 months if kept in airtight jars. If water-bath canned properly, your pickles are shelf-stable for up to 1 year in a cool, dark pantry. Once opened, store them in the fridge and use within 2–3 months.

Always check for spoilage signs like cloudiness, off smells, or bulging lids. When in doubt, toss them out. Need more storage-friendly dishes? Check out our apple cinnamon blondies with maple cream—perfect for fall pantry snacks.

Delicious Ways to Serve These Pickles

Bread and butter pickles shine in so many dishes. Add them to:

• Pulled pork sliders
• Grilled cheese sandwiches
• Fried chicken wraps
• Classic cheeseburgers
• Deviled eggs
• Potato salads
• Charcuterie boards

They also make a fantastic side for any creamy or smoky main dish.

Pairing Ideas for Meals and Snacks

Looking to create a full Southern-style spread? Serve these pickles with:

• BBQ brisket and baked beans
• Buttermilk fried chicken
• Mac and cheese
• Cornbread muffins

Or go snack-style: pair with cheese cubes, crackers, and cold cuts for an easy, flavorful platter. You could even chop them finely and fold them into your own homemade tartar sauce.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bread and Butter Pickles

Conclusion: Make This Timeless Pickle Recipe Part of Your Pantry

Whether you’re preserving a summer harvest or looking for that perfect crunchy bite to balance your meals, bread and butter pickles are an easy, versatile, and delicious addition to any kitchen. With their unique balance of sweet and tangy, they pair beautifully with countless dishes—from burgers to BBQ to salads. Follow these simple steps and tips, and you’ll have a jar of homemade goodness ready to impress.

Don’t miss our yellow squash casserole recipe if you’re craving more Southern-style comfort food.

Print