Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese – The Creamiest Classic Comfort Dish

Few side dishes hold the same warm, nostalgic charm as Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese. Rich, creamy, and baked to golden perfection, this beloved comfort food is a Sunday supper staple and holiday favorite across the South. In this guide, we’re diving deep into the traditional custard-style mac and cheese—made with real eggs, evaporated milk, and layers of gooey cheese. Whether you’re new to Southern cooking or looking to master the real deal, this recipe delivers all the cheesy goodness you’ve been craving.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Creamy Broccoli Cheese Soup Recipe for another comforting classic.

JUMP TO

Table of Contents

What Makes Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese So Special?

A Soul Food Staple with Rich History

Southern baked mac and cheese isn’t just a dish—it’s tradition served in a casserole dish. Its roots trace back to African American communities where the combination of creamy cheese and pasta became a centerpiece for gatherings and celebrations. This iconic side has long graced tables at Sunday dinners, church potlucks, and Thanksgiving feasts, passed down through generations as a labor of love.

What sets it apart from other versions? The soul. Southern-style mac and cheese is made to be baked, not stirred on the stovetop. It’s built for structure, flavor, and memories.

Custard-Style vs. Creamy Stove-Top: What’s the Difference?

If you’re used to creamy stovetop mac and cheese, the Southern version might surprise you. Instead of relying solely on cheese sauce, it uses a custard base made from eggs and evaporated milk. This custard binds everything together, resulting in a firmer, sliceable texture—almost like a savory macaroni pie.

Stovetop mac may win on speed, but baked Southern mac shines in flavor depth, richness, and satisfying chew. It’s not runny or overly saucy. It’s dense, hearty, and layered with melty cheese from top to bottom.

The Velveeta Controversy: Tradition vs. Taste

Ask any Southern cook and you’ll get strong opinions about Velveeta. Some say it’s a must, others snub it for sharp cheddar. But truth be told, many iconic recipes—including those inspired by Miss Robbie of Sweetie Pie’s fame—insist on Velveeta for that signature creamy finish.

While artisan cheeses might impress guests, Velveeta brings that ultra-smooth melt and nostalgic taste that defines true Southern baked macaroni and cheese. Pair it with grated Colby Jack and sharp cheddar, and you’ve got the perfect balance of silky texture and bold flavor.

Don’t miss our Southern Green Bean Casserole Recipe for another Southern favorite to round out your plate.

Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese Recipe Breakdown

Ingredients You’ll Need (with Substitutions)

Here’s what you’ll need to recreate this classic. Stick close to the original for authenticity, but feel free to adapt with what’s in your fridge.

Ingredient	Quantity	Notes / Substitutions
Elbow macaroni	8–10 oz	Slightly undercooked (al dente)
Whole milk	½ cup	Adds creaminess; can sub 2% milk
Evaporated milk	12 oz can	Essential for custard-style texture
Eggs	2, lightly beaten	Helps set the structure
White pepper	1½ tsp	Milder than black pepper
Granulated sugar	1½ tsp	Adds balance and slight sweetness
Salt	½ tsp or to taste	Taste before baking
Butter	½ cup (1 stick)	Cut into small pieces
Sour cream	2 tbsp	Adds tang and richness
Velveeta cheese	½ pound, cubed	Don’t substitute! It’s the base of creaminess
Colby-Jack cheese	8 oz shredded	Can sub Monterey Jack or a blend
Sharp cheddar cheese	4 oz shredded	Bold flavor
Mild cheddar cheese	1 cup, shredded	For that perfect golden top

Learn more about cheesy classics in our Creamiest Baked Mashed Potatoes Recipe.

Step-by-Step Preparation Method

1. Preheat oven to 350ºF.
2. Boil macaroni in salted water until al dente (just shy of package directions). Drain and pour into a 9×13” baking dish.
3. In the same pot, whisk together whole milk, evaporated milk, eggs, white pepper, salt, and sugar. Pour mixture over macaroni.
4. Add butter, sour cream, Velveeta, Colby Jack, and sharp cheddar. Stir gently to combine evenly.
5. Top with shredded mild cheddar.
6. Bake uncovered for 35–40 minutes until bubbling and lightly golden.
7. Let rest 10 minutes before serving to set properly.

Looking for something sweet to finish off your meal? Don’t miss our Sour Cherry Crumble Bars Recipe—a perfect fruity ending!

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Baking

• Don’t overcook your pasta. It will keep cooking in the oven.
• Don’t skip Velveeta. It’s not a suggestion—it’s the base.
• Grate your own cheese. Pre-shredded cheese doesn’t melt as smoothly.
• Let it rest. Cutting too soon leads to a messy slice. Letting it settle ensures creamy, set squares.

Discover great ideas like our Black People’s Pound Cake Recipe for another dish rooted in soul food tradition.

Serving Suggestions & Delicious Pairings

Best Dishes to Serve With Southern Baked Mac and Cheese

This cheesy casserole may be the star, but it plays beautifully with other southern classics. Traditionally served as a side dish, Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese shines alongside rich, savory flavors and deep-fried favorites.

Try pairing it with:

• Fried chicken – crispy on the outside, juicy inside.
• Collard greens – for balance and a hint of bitterness.
• Candied yams – to add sweet contrast to cheesy richness.
• Barbecue ribs – smoky, tender, and dripping with sauce.

Looking for inspiration? Try our Creamy Broccoli Cheese Soup on the side or as a cozy starter. Want to keep it all in the family? Serve it up with our fan-favorite Southern Green Bean Casserole and let the flavors melt together.

How to Store and Reheat for Best Results

This dish stores surprisingly well, making it perfect for leftovers or make-ahead meal plans.

• Refrigerator: Store covered in the fridge for up to 4 days.
• Freezer: Wrap tightly in foil and place in a freezer-safe bag or container for up to 2 months.
• Reheating Tips:
  • Microwave: Great for quick portions, just add a splash of milk before heating to prevent dryness.
  • Oven: Cover with foil and reheat at 325ºF until hot (15–20 minutes). For a crisp top, remove foil during the last 5 minutes.

Avoid overheating, as it can break the creamy custard and turn your mac oily. Instead, reheat gently to maintain that velvety texture.

Can It Be Made Ahead or Frozen?

Yes, absolutely—and this makes it a holiday hero.

To make ahead:

• Assemble the entire dish (uncooked), cover, and refrigerate for up to 24 hours.
• Bake just before serving.

To freeze:

• Assemble and freeze unbaked. Let it thaw overnight in the fridge and bake as directed.

Freezing after baking is also an option, but the texture may not be as perfect. It’s best when freshly baked—but that doesn’t mean you can’t plan ahead!

Customizing Your Macaroni and Cheese

Making It Spicy or Smoky

The beauty of Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese lies in its flexibility. While the classic recipe sticks to cheese, milk, and pasta, you can easily turn up the flavor with creative add-ins.

Spicy Upgrades:

• Diced jalapeños
• Hot sauce (try a splash of Tabasco)
• Pepper jack cheese

Smoky Twists:

• Crumbled bacon or smoked sausage
• Smoked paprika or chipotle powder
• Smoked gouda instead of sharp cheddar

These extras bring a new dimension while keeping the dish deeply satisfying.

Vegetarian & Gluten-Free Adaptations

Want to enjoy this classic without dairy or gluten? Totally doable with a few smart swaps.

For Gluten-Free:

• Use gluten-free elbow pasta (brown rice or quinoa-based work best).
• Check that your evaporated milk and cheese are gluten-free certified.

For Vegetarian:

• This dish is already vegetarian-friendly! Just ensure your cheese and sour cream are free from animal rennet (for strict vegetarians).

For Dairy-Free:

• Use plant-based cheeses that melt well (like Daiya).
• Coconut or oat-based evaporated milk replacements work surprisingly well in the custard base.

You’ll sacrifice some authenticity, but you’ll still get a hearty, satisfying meal.

Feeding a Crowd? Scale Up or Down Easily

Need to adjust for a potluck or smaller household? Use this guide to scale:

Servings	Elbow Macaroni	Eggs	Evaporated Milk	Total Cheese (combined)
4 servings	6 oz	1	½ can	2 cups
8 servings	10 oz	2	1 can	4 cups
12 servings	1 lb	3	1½ cans	6 cups

Note: Increase butter, sour cream, and seasoning accordingly.

Make it ahead for easy party planning or double the batch to freeze for busy weeknights. If you love prepping ahead, check out our Black People’s Pound Cake Recipe—another dish that tastes even better the next day!

FAQs About Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese

Final Thoughts: A Southern Dish Worth Mastering

Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese is more than just comfort food—it’s a rich, cultural tradition wrapped in creamy, cheesy goodness. Whether you’re serving it up for Sunday dinner, potluck, or holiday feast, this baked beauty brings people together. With a custard-style base, real butter, and the unbeatable melt of Velveeta and cheddar, it delivers deep flavor and unmatched texture.

And remember—make it yours. Add a smoky twist, a spicy kick, or scale it for a crowd. However you serve it, it’s bound to be the most talked-about dish at the table.

Don’t miss our Sour Cherry Crumble Bars for a sweet finish after this soul-satisfying classic.

Print